Monday-Friday : 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM EST
A federal appeals court just threw out a $200,000 restitution order. Not because the man owed nothing. Because the court ordered him to pay for a crime he was never convicted of.
The case is United States v. Malakhov, decided by the Second Circuit on November 12, 2026. It is a published decision, which means other courts in the circuit have to take it seriously. And it answers a question a lot of families quietly live with for years: where did this restitution number actually come from?
Here is what happened. Arkady Malakhov ran a small research company that received grant money from the National Science Foundation, $200,000 across two payments. He spent part of that money on expenses that had nothing to do with the research project, including personal and unrelated business costs. He later admitted it and pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor, conversion of government property.
The sentence was probation. But the judge also ordered him to pay back the entire $200,000 as restitution, treating the whole grant as the government's loss.
On appeal, Malakhov argued two things. First, he said restitution on a misdemeanor like his should be capped at $1,000. The court said no. There is no cap like that, and a smaller charge does not automatically mean a smaller financial obligation. That part of the decision is a warning worth hearing plainly: negotiating a reduced charge does not, by itself, reduce what someone can be ordered to repay.
His second argument is the one that won. Restitution is supposed to cover the loss caused by the specific conduct behind the conviction. Malakhov was convicted of converting part of the grant money after it arrived. He was not convicted of fraudulently getting the grant in the first place. The district court had calculated the $200,000 using the broader fraud theory, the idea that the government never would have paid anything if it had known the full story. The Second Circuit said that is not how restitution works. The amount has to be tied to the offense of conviction, the crime described in the plea and admitted in court. The court vacated the restitution order and sent the case back down to redo the calculation under the right rule.
This is where the decision matters beyond one case.
There is a number problem that follows a lot of people home from federal sentencing. The presentence report often lists a large loss figure, because the sentencing guidelines can count a wider circle of conduct. Families see that number and assume it is also the restitution number. It is not automatic. Guidelines loss and restitution are two different calculations, under two different sets of rules. Restitution needs a victim, an actual loss, and a direct line back to the offense of conviction. When a restitution order simply copies the bigger number, Malakhov says that order can be challenged.
None of this means restitution goes away. The court was clear that Malakhov can still be ordered to repay the actual loss his conversion caused, and on remand the district court will set a new amount. What changed is the measuring stick. The government has to prove the loss that belongs to the conviction, not the loss that belongs to its broadest version of the case.
Two limits are worth stating plainly. First, a plea agreement can agree to broader restitution than the offense of conviction alone would allow, and where the law or the agreement authorizes more, this decision does not take that away. Second, for a judgment that is already final, Malakhov does not automatically undo an existing restitution order, and it does not guarantee anyone relief. What it does is establish the question that has to be asked of every restitution number: was this amount actually supported by the offense of conviction, the statute, the plea agreement, and proof of a real loss? Restitution needs its own analysis. It should never just be accepted because it appeared in the presentence report.
If someone in your family is carrying a restitution order, a few questions are worth asking of the paperwork itself. Does the amount in the judgment match the offense named in the plea agreement? Did the court work out an actual loss, or adopt a larger figure from somewhere else in the file? Did anyone get repaid, or any property returned, in a way that should have lowered the number? The judgment and the plea documents answer most of that, and they are the same pages worth reading closely for everything else in a case.
You can pull a federal docket and read the judgment with our free Federal Case Locator at https://prosehelpllc.com/assets/tools/federal-case-locator.html. This article is general information about a new court decision, not legal advice about any one case. Restitution questions are fact-specific, and deadlines in federal cases are real, so treat the paperwork as the starting point, not the finish line.